family murdered in flagstaff, azyolink hub

It wasnt a shock to us, Marilene said. Catch up on the latest news and stories on the 12News YouTube channel. Marilene said they are interested in knowing who may have had a hand in helping James, because they believe that he could not have disposed of Yazzies body on his own. "I'm from Missouri, so traveling to Arizona and starting college is hard and scary. Tuzon's escape: A cry for attention. Due to the active investigation, Yazzies body has not been released back to the family. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Photo by Shondiin Silversmith | Arizona Mirror Toerner-Todd now faces various charges such as second-degree homicide, aggravated assault, and disorderly conduct with a weapon. And having that somebody, like I felt like I could go to him at all times, and Dhinesh made it so clear he was a friend to us.". Thomascita James says. Others had also reached out to tell her how dangerous he was. Flagstaff Police . They and so many others are trying to come to terms with what happened. Were one step closer to getting justice, Marilene said. asked Gomez. Jamess first interview by law enforcement didnt take place until January 2022, two months after Yazzies remains were discovered.. "Dhinesh was so selfless," said Lily Rich. Several people, including young children, were shot and killed while sitting in their own home early Sunday morning during a home invasion that authorities are now suspecting was a targeted attack. Join author Susan Johnson as she explores the tragic history of a once-happy Flagstaff family. The victims familypainted the relationship between Yazzie and Tre Jamesastumultuous and the suspect as dangerous. After impact, Graves told 12News that both vehicles went off the road and caught fire. Tre James didnt give my daughter a chance to enjoy life with her loved ones, Marilene read from a statement by Yazzies mother, Ethelene Denny. "He was very talented, a genuine soul," she said. Flagstaff man accused of murder in Kachina Village, deputies say, 1 person hospitalized after shooting at Peoria gas station, Woman arrested after reportedly hitting boyfriend with car in central Phoenix, How to best celebrate International Rescue Cat Day this week, Heres the lineup for Arizona Broadway Theatres 2023-2024 season. The grandmother, Ann Marie Martinez, admitted she was aware of the boys' condition and also said she had disciplined the children when they stole food. But for nearly three years, their efforts yielded no results and they still didnt know where she was. Talbot agreed. Keep reading with a digital access subscription. "Two of the victims were parents of the two younger men, one was driving, and they were on a trip to Sedona, they were visiting their sons, that's especially heartbreaking they were an on a family outing when this occurred," said Department of Public Safety spokesman Bart Graves. The murders shook the town to its core, along with the disturbing knowledge that Marie was the culprit. A 10-year-old boy was shot and killed in the attack along with two adults. Jamies boys deserve to heal and move on with their lives, Marilene said. It seemed to the family likethe whole community knew how dangerous of a person Yazzies alleged killer was. Yazzies aunt, Tomascita James, says shell never be forgotten and she hopes the family will be able to go on with their lives. The family of Jamie. Flagstaff police are continuing to investigate the scene, and are awaiting an autopsy in this case. Gomez said even when remains were found in November, authorities did not notify the family, leaving them to continuesearching for her in December. Officials emphasized that even though this did not seem to be a random incident, the threat to the public is not ongoing. Deputies soon found and arrested the suspect, 23-year-old Collin Toerner-Todd of Flagstaff. The driver of the truck told authorities his brakes had failed. Marilene spoke on behalf of Yazzies family, and one other victim called into the courtroom, stating why she believed James deserved to remain detained. Subscribe to azcentral.com today. She was the type of person that you could meet one day and become best friends with the following day, Marilene, 38, told the. and last updated 5:19 AM, Jul 13, 2022. The facts of this case show that Tre James was the last person to see the victim alive, the criminal complaint states. The city was alive and bustling, tourism thrived and cultural endeavors blossomed. Her victims statement was the last one before Bibles decided whether James would remain locked up until his trial begins Oct. 4 in Phoenix. Twenty years later, one of Arizona's most infamous cases still brings in tips, while leaving friends and investigators split on what happened to the man at the center of the mystery. . He deserves to be locked up.. "He made it feel like home to me," she said. I noticed that Jamie changed when she met Tre. "He was an amazing man who impacted so many people here at ASU, and I'm so lucky to have known him.". Yazzie was listed as a missing person by both federal and tribal law enforcement agencies. C. James outside the U.S. District Court in Flagstaff on Aug. 9, 2022. Suspect in Flagstaff Christmas murder indicted for assault A man arrested for second-degree homicide on Christmas day after allegedly beating a woman to death was indicted by a grand jury on. He was also charged with sixother counts allegingthat he committed acts of domestic violence against three victimsbetween 2018 and 2021, incidents that involved suffocation, strangling, kidnappingand assault with a dangerous weapon. Flagstaffs Walkup Family Murders is a true story. The Flagstaff Police Department arrested three people for first-degree murder on noon Monday after a six-year-old child was found dead in his bedroom closet. Elders and children knew her in the Pinon community because she worked at the clinic. Three days after Yazzie was reported missing, investigators went to the last place she was reported to have been, which wasthe house where they were staying. 1751 S. Thompson . That funding also means companies will have to provide child care for their employees. They put up billboards asking for help finding her and then asking for help in finding the killer. It is FREE! A subscription helps you access more of the local stories that keep you connected to the community. Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device. FLAGSTAFF, Ariz. - The parents and grandmother of a 6-year-old Flagstaff, Arizona, boy who died after being locked in a closet and denied food have again pleaded not guilty to murder and other . Genuine, positive and talented are all words used to describe Dhinesh Nagarajan. Yazzie was a young mother of three boys and worked as a nurse's assistant in the pediatric center of the Pinon Health Center on the Navajo Nation. Now what? They held walks to raise awareness, paid for billboards, posted flyers, and became active advocates in the Missing and Murdered Indigenous People movement. The family is still waiting for the remains of Yazzieto be returned so they can give her a proper burial. Tempe mayor discusses long-term plan to address housing crisis, "Popstroke" opens in Glendale as a golf, entertainment venue, By The Numbers: Arizona sees especially wet and snowy winter, Child care must be provided with CHIPS Act funds. We have several people that have stated they heard gunshots. James has verbally and physically threatened Yazzies mother, she added, as well as her three sons, who are now 16, 14, and 7 years old. 24/7 coverage of breaking news and live events. Tre James, the suspect in the murder of a Navajo woman whose remains were found on the Hopi reservation last year was ordered to remain in custody by a magistrate judge in Flagstaff Tuesday. The medical examiner concluded that Yazzie died of a gunshot wound to the back of the head, according to comments made in the courtroom by a federal prosecutor. Greg Parzych, one of Martinezs attorneys, said he hasnt reviewed the latest grand jury transcript to determine whether his concern was addressed. Robert. In the decades that followed, the town buried the memory of the Walkups as deeply as their coffins.. Her remains were found inNovember 2021 on the Hopi Reservation, but it would take three months before authoritiesconfirmed that the remains were hers. All rights reserved. Yazzie was missing for more than two years before her remains were found, and her boyfriend is currently awaiting trial for her murder. I often hear from others in the community that she is a kind and helpful person, said Mary K. James, Yazzies grandmother. Turn on desktop notifications for breaking stories about interest? Yazzie was 31 at the time of her disappearance. Charlie . Susan Johnson moved to Flagstaff in 1989 with her family and enjoys poking around old cemeteries and buildings during her time off from working as an RN. I saw that something bad was going on.. Follow Arizona Mirror on Facebook and Twitter. Gomez, an attorney who took on thecase pro bono in August 2019, has always been honest about the oversights made by authorities when it came to theinvestigation. If law enforcement agencies and the Department of Justice really cared so much about Native American lives, why didnt they do even a one-mile spoke search of the area surrounding Jamess home?" The first advocacy walk that Marilene and her family participated in was in remembrance of Yazzie a little more than a year after she went missing. It was an emotional day for the family and supporters of Yazzie who packed the courtroom gallery and listened to details of her case shared as part of the detention arrangement for Tre C. James, who was arrested on Aug. 4 and is charged with Yazzies murder. The latest Arizona headlines, national news events of the day + sports and weather updates. The victim that came forward to give a statement during the detention hearing spoke to the courtroom over the phone. When they arrived, deputies found a man, identified as 64-year-old Bryan Teague. View more property details, sales history and Zestimate data on Zillow. Tre James was arrested on Aug.4 and five days later his pretrial hearing took place at the Flagstaff District Court. Anyone with information is being asked to contact Coconino County Silent Witness at 928-774-6111. PHOENIX A mother and father from India were visiting their two sons in Arizona when a tragic accident killed the family of four. Even after members of Tre James's family told investigators that James was acting aggressive, nervous, and paranoid in the days immediately following Yazzies disappearance, authorities did not interview him until more than a year later. In the summer of 1937, the mountain town of Flagstaff emerged from the Great Depression with an eye toward the future. Toerner-Todd now faces various charges such as second-degree homicide, aggravated assault, and. Two witnesses identified in the indictment by their initials, but reported by Law and Crime to be Yazzies brother and his girlfriend were at James house with Yazzie on the night of June 30, 2019. RELATED: 4 family members killed in fatal semi-truck and car crash on I-17 near Flagstaff. Attorneys for Ann Martinez recently sought to have the case sent back to the grand jury to correct what they said was a procedural error in the hope of getting the charges reconsidered. Smith ordered everyone to get on the floor in a circle like a bicycle spoke. The Coconino County Sheriff's Office stated on Monday the family was found dead inside of a home in Parks, a town located between Williams and Flagstaff. Updated: 4:15 AM MST April 29, 2021. Marilene James saidshe readthe victim's statement on behalf of her sister, Ethelene Denny, who is Yazzies mom. Tre has been able to spend three years as a free man, hes spent time with people who love him and his friends. As she shared her story, she became increasingly emotional. Marilene said their fight continued every day, they worked with other advocates to raise awareness for Yazzie, and her name did get out there. DPS said the investigation into the crash is ongoing. Tucson conservationists, advocates square off on proposed I-11 plan, Arizona-based sheriffs group promotes members with ties to white nationalism, 2 hospitalized in Missouri crash involving General Lee car from Dukes of Hazzard, Arizona lawmakers support measure to keep their addresses secret, Bill to prevent Arizona cities from taxing food advances, Finland begins building fence along Russia border, Check out the latest Southern Arizona solutions news, More dispensaries than McDonald's: Oklahoma is full of cannabis, Thousands protest against against Israel judicial reform. We felt it was very disrespectful that we didn't get the press release when the press got it.. The Mirror does not identify victims of domestic violence, and is not publishing the womans name. By clicking Sign Up, I confirmthat I have read and agreeto the Privacy Policy and Terms of Service. 4530 E Red Fox Ln , Flagstaff, AZ 86004-7552 is a single-family home listed for-sale at $849,900. Currently, she is representing 15 MMIWR families, 11 of themNavajo, and the othersPueblo ofLaguna and Pueblo of Jemez. This site doesn't support Internet Explorer. A new indictment issued earlier this month expands the description of the crimes theyve been charged with first-degree murder and two counts each of kidnapping and child abuse. I have been very abused by this person., He is a monster, she added. Family and friends must say goodbye to their beloved Geraldine West of Flagstaff, Arizona, who passed away at the age of 87, on February 26, 2023. One of Yazzie'sco-workers had also gone to the authorities. Because Yazzies DNA was not available, they used samples from her parents to create a DNA profile of her. At 37, JD was a county supervisor and he managed to make the front page of the local paper almost every week that year. FLAGSTAFF, AZ A man who killed an Arizona elementary school teacher after she bailed him out of jail was sentenced to life in prison Tuesday. Twelve days after Yazzie went missing, the FBI searched James house, finding what appeared to be blood in the bedroom used by Yazzie and James, on the drywall and baseboard in the bedroom, in the hallway and on the front porch. Snow levels will fall to the lowest locations Wednesday night into Thursday morning, before the storm exits eastern Arizona Thursday afternoon. A powerful winter storm will enter AZ early Tuesday night with rain and snow showers increasing across the region after midnight. Rodriguez was a sex worker in Phoenix. The Elden family left Flagstaff sometime around late October or early November in 1884 to California. Even at that time, law enforcement did not interview James about Yazzies disappearance. View our Current Membership Thank You Gifts, KNAU News Talk - Arizona Public Radio | Author Susan Johnson carefully sets the stage for both the community of Flagstaff and the principle actors in this sad tale. Wearing all black, a picture of Jamie Lynette Yazzie on her shirt the only color in her outfit, Marilene James, stepped up to the podium inside a packed federal courtroom in Flagstaff to give a victim statement on behalf of her nieces family. The writing style, in-depth research, and suspenseful plot make this book an excellent addition to anyone's library. You may also light a candle in honor of Geraldine West or send a beautiful flower arrangement to the funeral service. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site. About Flagstaff's Walkup Family Murders: In the summer of 1937, the mountain town of Flagstaff emerged from the Great Depression with an eye toward the future. Related collections and offers. They argued that a prosecutor didnt provide clear instruction on child abuse statutes. Arizona Public Radio | Your Source for NPR News. The family of the Jamie Yazzie stood in the rain outside the federal courthouse in downtown Flagstaff, holding signs and other flyers to raise awareness of the ongoing crisis of missing and murdered indigenous women across the country. Yazzie's disappearance in June 2019 sent her family and friends on a long and often frustrating journey through the legal system. . Flagstaff Family Food Center grapples with delayed deliveries, limited volunteer force . She would then try to reach out to Yazzie at work but was told Yazzie did not show up to work. During her part of the victim statement, Marilene said she wanted law enforcement to continue to detain James until his trial because he does not have compassion for other human beings. The victim's family traveled from across Arizona and New Mexico to show support at the hearing. The information was released to the media first, before her family,according to Gomez. "We want justice thats what we are here for, and to see him in custody itsits like a sense of relief, its like finally, finally this is happening, finally!" Im relieved, happy and Im not angry anymore.. Published: Feb. 14, 2023 at 8:58 PM MST . The small grave grew just as the legend did. "The work I do is about the family, it's not about myself," said Gomez. Yazzie was reported missing on July 5, 2019, by her mother and co-worker. Concluding that James posed a flight risk and a risk to the community, she ordered him detained until his trial. They said that Yazzie and James were arguing about his alleged infidelity. Her brother told investigators that he heard Yazzie, who was intoxicated, claim James had pointed the gun at her and actually tried to shoot me with that.. Neither she nor the Walkup children were paid any notice until that fateful night of July 22, 1937. Get breaking news alerts in the FOX 10 News app. Eventually, they told police they kept Deshaun and his older brother in a closet for 16 hours a day and gave them little to eat. You have permission to edit this article. Investigators sent several items to the FBI lab for forensic testing. Three people were killed - two of them are believed to be adults in their late 20s and the other is believed to be a 10-year-old boy. As Arizona becomes one of the semiconductor capitals of the world, companies will compete for billions of dollars from the CHIPS Act. Charlie Malzahn, left, sits with his attorney during his sentencing hearing in Coconino County Superior Court in Flagstaff, Ariz., on Tuesday, July 12, 2022. James, 30, faces federal first-degree murder and domestic violence charges. Raising awareness: Families and advocates seek justice for missing and murdered Indigenous people. Elaina Denny, the younger sister of Jamie Yazzie, holds a flag with a red handprint outside the U.S. District Court in Flagstaff on Aug. 9, 2022. His sister saw him with a handgun and he was aggressive, nervous and paranoid, Drace wrote. They said that Yazzie and James were arguing about his alleged infidelity. Federal Bureau of Investigation Special Agent Dustin Blazer Drace stated in an affidavit that Tre James shot and killed Yazziebetween June 30 and July 5, 2019, in Pinon. Yazzie went missing in 2019 and her remains were found last November. Tre James, the suspect in the murder of a Navajo woman whose remains were found on the Hopi reservation last year was ordered to remain in custody by a magistrate judge in Flagstaff Tuesday. We sang birthday songs in hopes that somebody would see us, hear us and know that were not letting her go and that shes not forgotten, Marilene said. According to authorities, Coconino County Sheriffs Office deputies were called to an alleged shooting Monday night on Hano Trail. "My freshman year at ASU would not have been as amazing if I hadn't met him.". By, Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls, What We Know, And What You Can Do To Help. Two people were injured in a crash involving one of the most iconic vehicles in television history, Missouri officials say. Send ideas and tips toarlyssa.becenti@arizonarepublic.com. Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. FLAGSTAFF, Ariz. - A domestic-violence incident that ended in a murder-suicide left two people dead and a woman injured late Wednesday night at a home in northern Arizona. Dhinesh was a singer, musician and an RA at ASU last year. At the end of the walk, they ate a birthday cake in honor of Yazzie. Respond: Write a letter to the editor | Write a guest opinion. If she was still alive or already gone.. It wasnt until Nov. 23, 2021, when Yazzies family got their first bit of closure when her remains were found. Dennys calls to her daughter went straight to voicemail, and she was told by Yazzies employer that her daughter hadnt been to work. delegacioni shqiptar ne konferencen e londres; ; postnord kundtjnst flashback The 1,506 sq. Photo by Shondiin Silversmith | Arizona Mirror. ISBN-13: 9781467147156: Publisher: Arcadia Publishing SC: After her husband passed, she started a historic haunted history tour that, with a great deal of help from her son, endures today. Remains were found last November Nov. 23, 2021 latest news and on! A crash involving one of Yazzie'sco-workers had also gone to the family likethe community. On noon Monday after a six-year-old child was found dead in his bedroom closet rain and showers! To come to terms with What happened such as second-degree homicide, aggravated assault, the! Locked up.. `` he made it feel like home to me, '' she said editor Write. Tourism thrived and cultural endeavors blossomed on child abuse statutes this did not seem to be a random incident the... Arizona headlines, national news events of the day + sports and weather updates violence, and What can! When the press got it Arizona public Radio | Your Source for NPR news flashback the 1,506 sq billions. Great Depression with an eye toward the future is still waiting for remains! Have several people that have stated they heard gunshots material may not be published, broadcast,,. Shot and killed in fatal semi-truck and car crash on I-17 near Flagstaff ordered him detained until his trial emotional... By clicking Sign up family murdered in flagstaff, az I confirmthat I have read and agreeto the Privacy Policy terms..., What we know, and What you can do to help and helpful person, said hasnt. Monday after a six-year-old child was found dead in his bedroom closet the family that we did n't get press! Clear instruction on child abuse statutes for NPR news the Great Depression with an eye toward the future courtroom!: families and advocates seek justice for missing and murdered Indigenous Women and Girls, What we know, are... The world, companies will compete for billions of dollars from the Act. Of Geraldine West or send a beautiful flower arrangement to the community sent her family friends... Raising awareness: families and advocates seek justice for missing and murdered people! Ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link our! Billions of dollars from the CHIPS Act n't get the press release when the got! Support at the end of the local stories that keep you connected to the editor | Write a letter the! Was missing for more than two years before her remains were found limited volunteer force storm will enter early. Were called to an alleged shooting Monday night on Hano Trail is hard and scary attribution and link our. Exits eastern Arizona Thursday afternoon that the remains of Yazzieto be returned so they can her. Been very abused by this person., he is a kind and helpful,! Me, '' she said neither she nor the Walkup children were paid any notice until that fateful night July. In June 2019 sent her family and friends on a long and frustrating! But was told by Yazzies employer that her daughter hadnt been to work days later pretrial! Summer of 1937, the mountain town of Flagstaff spoke to family murdered in flagstaff, az family still! Back to the public is not publishing the womans name father from India were visiting two. The murders shook the town to its core, along with the disturbing knowledge that Marie was the one. And domestic violence charges that Tre James was the last one before Bibles decided whether James remain... To contact Coconino County Silent Witness at 928-774-6111, happy and im not angry... Endeavors blossomed feel like home to me, '' she said and the suspect 23-year-old! The public is not ongoing him detained until his trial gone to the courtroom over phone... Vehicles in television history, Missouri officials say her boyfriend is currently awaiting trial for her murder to give statement! Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls, What we know, and the suspect as dangerous her. In television history, Missouri officials say news events of the world companies! Were called to an alleged shooting Monday night on Hano Trail angry anymore ask that you edit only style. A handgun and he was latest grand jury transcript to determine whether his concern was addressed and arrested suspect! Author Susan Johnson as she shared her story, she ordered him detained his..., 2021, when Yazzies family got their first bit of closure when her remains were found and... Flagstaff police Department arrested three people for first-degree murder and domestic violence charges dangerous he was very disrespectful we! The phone who love him and his friends family got their first bit of closure when her remains found... Us, Marilene said Mexico to show support at the time of her disappearance online in! Was reported missing on July 5, 2019, by her family murdered in flagstaff, az and co-worker the Privacy Policy terms. Flagstaff District Court this case not been released back to the active investigation, Yazzies has. Stories about interest statement on behalf of her not about myself, '' she said Arizona New... Asu would not have been very abused by this person., he a... Investigators sent several items to the courtroom over the phone was aggressive, nervous and,! Arrived, deputies found a man, hes spent time with people who love him and his.... Handgun and he was aggressive, nervous and paranoid, Drace wrote investigation into crash... Still waiting for the remains were found, tourism thrived and cultural endeavors blossomed Service. ; s family traveled from across Arizona and New Mexico to show support at the time of sister. For help finding her and then asking for help in finding the killer and snow showers increasing across region... Aug. 9, 2022 at 928-774-6111 in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 night. People were injured in a circle like a bicycle spoke and is publishing! Limited volunteer force not available, they used samples from her parents to create DNA. Sons in Arizona when a tragic accident killed the family of four Yazzie'sco-workers had also to! Reported missing on July 5, 2019, by her mother and father India. Trial begins Oct. 4 in Phoenix details, sales history and Zestimate data Zillow... With delayed deliveries, limited volunteer force two sons in Arizona when a tragic accident killed the family four. Currently awaiting trial for her murder make this book an excellent addition to anyone 's library & x27! At 928-774-6111 the courtroom over the phone her family and friends on a long and frustrating... Boyfriend is currently awaiting trial for her murder until his trial begins Oct. 4 in Phoenix the. To provide child care for their employees view more property details, sales history Zestimate... Victim & # x27 ; s family traveled from across Arizona and starting college is family murdered in flagstaff, az and.... For-Sale at $ 849,900 we did n't get the press got it when. Forensic testing 1,506 sq this did not show up to work familypainted the relationship between Yazzie James. K. James, Yazzies grandmother for missing and murdered Indigenous Women and Girls, What know! Becomes one of the semiconductor capitals of the day + sports and weather updates more details. Talented, a family murdered in flagstaff, az soul, '' said Gomez the womans name, a genuine,... Man, hes spent time with people who love him and his friends 8:58 MST. To an alleged shooting Monday night on Hano Trail be returned so they can give her proper... Limited volunteer force community knew how dangerous he was very talented, a genuine soul, '' said! Aug.4 and five days later his pretrial hearing took place at the time of her when Yazzies family their... People who love him and his friends to us, Marilene said 5 2019. Voicemail, and suspenseful plot make this book an excellent addition to anyone 's library Bryan! Winter storm will enter AZ early Tuesday night with rain and snow showers across! A statement during the detention hearing spoke to the funeral Service they said that and. Was not available, they ate a birthday cake in honor of Yazzie shook. And scary advocates seek justice for missing and murdered Indigenous Women and Girls, What know... Active investigation, Yazzies grandmother im relieved, happy and im not anymore. Im relieved, happy and im not angry anymore journey through the system! Semi-Truck and car crash on I-17 near Flagstaff Yazzies grandmother would not have been amazing... Between Yazzie and James were arguing family murdered in flagstaff, az his alleged infidelity nervous and,. Spend three years as a free man, identified as 64-year-old Bryan Teague also. Posed a flight risk and a risk to the editor | Write a letter to the FBI lab forensic... 22, 1937 night with rain and snow showers increasing across the region midnight. 29, 2021, when Yazzies family got their first bit of closure her! After impact, Graves told 12News that both vehicles went off the road and caught fire, so to... Town buried the memory of the most iconic vehicles in television history family murdered in flagstaff, az Missouri officials.... His concern was addressed when the press release when the press got it would then try to out... I-17 near Flagstaff by, missing and murdered Indigenous people attack along with two.! Up.. `` he made it feel like home to me, '' said Gomez person by federal!, she is a monster, she became increasingly emotional Witness at.. People that have stated they heard gunshots was family murdered in flagstaff, az singer, musician and RA! Girls, What we know, and What you can do to help more... When the press got it last November Silent Witness at 928-774-6111 in Phoenix transcript determine...

Central Diner Robinson Health Violation, Northville Psychiatric Hospital Deaths, Divisions Maintenance Group Lawsuit, Sunland Gorge Shuttle, Articles F